Moneyball
movie quotes
unfold smoothly to give us one of those rare movies that
even those who couldn't care less about baseball or sports will find
engaging. The movie based on a book by Michael Lewis and it gives the
audience and interesting take on how to win at the game of baseball and
it's also based on the true story of real life Oakland A's general
manager Billy Beane (Brad Pitt) and how he turned around the team with
the help of an Ivy league graduate computer whiz Peter Brand (Jonah
Hill). The chemistry between Pitt and Hill helps drive the movie and
gives it life with
Pitt giving one of his best performances. Moneyball is a
sharp, shrewd,
intelligent and satisfying movie and for all the concentration on
numbers, it never loses sight of the fact that this is a game of people.
Directed
by: Bennett Miller
Written by:
Steven Zaillian (screenplay)
Aaron Sorkin (screenplay)
Stan Chervin (story)
Michael Lewis (book "Moneyball: The Art of Winning an Unfair Game") Starring: Brad Pitt -
Billy Beane
Jonah Hill - Peter Brand
Philip Seymour Hoffman - Art Howe
Robin Wright - Sharon
Chris Pratt - Scott Hatteberg
Stephen Bishop - David Justice
Brent Jennings - Ron Washington
Ken Medlock - Grady Fuson
Tammy Blanchard - Elizabeth Hatteberg
Jack McGee - John Poloni
Vyto Ruginis - Pittaro
Nick Searcy - Matt Keough
Glenn Morshower - Ron Hopkins
Casey Bond - Chad Bradford
Nick Porrazzo - Jeremy Giambi
Kerris Dorsey - Casey Beane
Arliss Howard - John Henry
Reed Thompson - Young Billy
James Shanklin - Billy's Dad
Diane Behrens - Billy's Mom
[Billy's is in his
boss's office talking about the game Billy's team lost] Stephen Schott:
How
are the guys doing? Billy Beane:
It was a killer. It was a killer. It was a tough one to swallow. It
was... Stephen Schott: Ah,
they played great. They did... Billy Beane: Oh,
they played their hearts out. They...they did, they played fantastic
and it just didn't fall our way. Stephen Schott: They'll
do better next year. Billy Beane: We
were close though, weren't we? We were so close, right there. Stephen Schott: You
almost had it. You gotta feel good about that. Billy Beane: Oh,
I feel great about. I feel great about it.
Billy Beane: Um...we're
not gonna do better next year. Stephen Schott: Why
not? Billy Beane: Well
you know we're being gutted. We're losing Giambi, Damon, Isringhausen.
Done deal. We're in trouble. Stephen Schott: You'll
find new guys. You found Jason, you found Damon. Billy Beane: We
need more money Steve. Stephen Schott: Bill. Billy Beane: I
need more money! Stephen Schott: We
don't have any more money. Billy Beane: I
can't
compete against a hundred and twenty million payroll with thirty eight
million dollars. Stephen Schott: We're
not gonna compete with these teams that have big budgets. We're gonna
work with the constraints that we have and you're gonna get
out and do the best job that you can recruiting new players. We're not
gonna pay seventeen million dollars a year to players. Billy Beane: I'm
not asking you for ten, twenty, thirty million dollars. I'm
just asking for a little bit of help. Just get me a little bit closer
and I will get you that championship team. I mean, this is why I'm
here. This is why you hired me. And I gotta ask you what are we doin'
here? Stephen Schott: Billy,
you know I... Billy Beane: If
it's not to win a championship? Stephen Schott: I
wanna win just as... [Billy holds his hand up
high] Billy Beane: That's
my bar. My bar is here. My bar is to take this team to the championship.
Stephen Schott: Bill
we're a small market team and you're a small market GM. I'm asking you
to be okay not spending money that I don't have. And I'm asking to take
a deep breath, shake off the loss, get back in a room with your guys
and figure out how to find replacements for the guys we lost with the
money that we do have. Billy Beane: I'm
not leaving here. I'm not...I'm not...I can't leave here with that. Stephen Schott: What
else can I help you with? [Billy looks despondent] Billy Beane: Yep.
[talking on the phone] Scott:
Billy? Scott. Just got off the phone with Dan. Billy Beane: No,
you didn't! Scott: I'm
surprised he even called me. Billy Beane: Scott,
I
got Johnny for seven point five and he doesn't play anywhere else, so
that's the deal you made. Scott: Well
he just upped it to seven seven five. [Billy doesn't answer] Scott: You
there? Billy Beane: We
had a deal, Scott. Scott: We
have a deal, if it's eight million. Billy Beane: Oh,
man! You played me. Scott: I'm
just doing my job... Billy Beane: No,
you're playing me and you're still playing me. Congratulations,
asshole! You win. [he hangs up the phone]
[at the scouts meeting
discussing the players] Grady Fuson:
Artie,
who do you like? Scout Artie:
I
like Perez. He's got a classy swing, it's a real clean stroke. Scout Barry:
He can't hit the curve ball. Scout Artie: Yeah,
there's some work to be done, I'll admit that. Scout Barry: Yeah,
there is. Scout Artie: But
he's noticeable. Matt Keough:
And
an ugly girlfriend. Scout Barry: What
does that mean? Matt Keough: Ugly
girl friend means no confidence. Scout Barry: Okay. John Poloni:
Oh, now,
you guys are full of it, Artie's right. This guy's
got an attitude and an attitude is good. I mean it's the kind of guy
who walks into a room his dick has already been there for two
minutes. Scout Pote:
He passes the eye candy test. He's got the looks, he's great at playing
the part. He just needs to get some playing time. Matt Keough: I'm
just saying his girlfriend is a six at best.
Grady Fuson: We're
trying to solve a problem here. Billy Beane:
Not like this you're not. You're not even looking at the problem. Grady Fuson:
We're
very aware of the problem. Billy Beane:
Okay, good. What's the problem? Grady Fuson:
Okay,
Billy. We all understand what the problem is. We have to
replace... Billy Beane:
Good. What's the problem? Grady Fuson: The
problem is we have to replace three key players. Billy Beane:
No. What's the problem? John Poloni: Same
as it's ever been. We've gotta replace these guys with what we
have existing. Billy Beane:
No! What's the problem, Barry? Scout Barry: We
need three eight home runs, a hundred twenty R.B.I's and forty
seven... Billy Beane:
Aaahhh! The problem we're trying to solve is that there are rich teams
and there are poor teams, then there's fifty feet of crap, and then
there's us. It's an unfair game. And now we're being gutted, organ
donors for the rich. Boston has taken our kidney's, Yankees takin' our
heart and you guys are sittin' around talkin' the same old good body
nonsense, like we're selling deeds. Like we're looking for Fabio. We
got to think differently.
Billy Beane: We
are the last dog at the ball. You've seen what happens to the runt of
the litter? He dies! Grady Fuson: Billy,
that's a very touching story and everything, but I think we're all very
much aware of what we're facing here. You have a lot of experience and
wisdom in this room, now you need to have a little bit of faith and let
us do the job of replacing Giambi. Billy Beane: Is
there another first base player like Giambi? John Poloni: No,
not really. Billy Beane: And
if there was, could we afford him? Grady Fuson: No. Billy Beane: Then
what the fuck are you talkin' about, man? If we try to play like the
Yankees in here, we will lose to the Yankees out there Grady Fuson: Boy,
that sounds like fortune cookie wisdom to me, Billy. Billy Beane: No,
that's just logic. Scout Bob:
Who's Fabio?
[at the offices of the
Cleveland Indians, Billy meets their GM to see if he can
procure some players] Mark Shapiro:
How's it going? Billy Beane: It's
goin' alright. How are you been? You're fillin' out that chair nicely. Mark Shapiro: Well
I got three weeks in it right now. Billy Beane: Good.
Good, man. Mark Shapiro: How
are you doin'? Billy Beane: Fantastic! Mark Shapiro: Awesome! Billy Beane: I
couldn't be better. Mark Shapiro: Well,
that's good to hear, Billy. I'm not gonna waste your time, man. You
just tell me what you're lookin' for. Billy Beane: Fifty
million dollars in additional payroll. Mark Shapiro: You
should try Giambi. Billy Beane: Ouch!
Mark Shapiro: I'm
sorry. It's too soon, right?
[as Billy is about to
leave the Cleveland office he comes back to Peter for making Shapiro
change his mind selling his players] Peter Brand: Hello. Billy Beane: Who
are you? Peter Brand:
I'm Peter Brand. Billy Beane: What
do you do? Peter Brand: I'm
special assistant to Mark Shapiro. Billy Beane: So
what do you do? Peter Brand: Mostly
player analysis right now. Billy Beane: Been
on the job long? First job in baseball? Peter Brand: It's
my first job anywhere. Billy Beane: Wow!
Congrats. Peter Brand: Thank
you. Billy Beane: First
job. Who's nephew are you? Why does Mark listen to you? Peter Brand: I
don't think uh...I don't think he does very often. Billy Beane: He
just did. Peter Brand: Well,
in that circumstance I think he was more listening to Bruce than myself.
Billy Beane: Who
are you? Peter Brand: I'm
Peter Brand. Billy Beane: I
don't give a rats ass what you're name is. What happened in there? What
happened in that room? Peter Brand: I'm
not quite sure why you're asking me, Mr. Beane. Billy Beane: What
did you tell, Bruce? Peter Brand: I
just told Bruce that I liked Garcia. Billy Beane: You
like Garcia. Why? Why? [Peter doesn't answer so
Billy gets up and leaves the office with Peter following him]
Peter Brand: There
is an epidemic failure within the game to understand what is
really happening and this leads people who run major league baseball
teams to misjudge their players and mismanage their teams. I apologize.
Billy Beane: Go
on. Peter Brand: Okay,
people who run ball clubs, they think in terms of buying players.
Your goal shouldn't be to buy players. Your goal should be to buy wins
and in order to buy wins, you need to buy your run. You're trying to
replace Johnny Damon. The Boston Red Sox see Johnny Damon and they see
a star who's worth seven and a half million dollars a year. When I see
Johnny Damon, what I see is...is an imperfect understanding of where
runs come from. The guy's got a great glove, he's a decent league off
hitter, he can steal bases. But is he worth the seven and a half
million
dollars a year the Boston Red Sox are paying him? No! No! Baseball
thinking is medieval, they are asking all the wrong questions and if I
say it to anybody I'm...I'm ostracized. I'm a rebel, so that's why
I'm...I'm cagey about this with you, that's why I respect you Mr. Beane
and if you want full disclosure, I think it's a good thing you got
Damon off of your payroll. I think it opens up all kinds of interesting
possibilities.
Billy Beane: Where
you from, Pete? Peter Brand: Maryland. Billy Beane: Where
did you go to school? Peter Brand: Yale,
I went to Yale. Billy Beane: What
did you study? Peter Brand: Economics.
I studied Economics. Billy Beane: Yale,
Economics, baseball. You're funny, Pete. [Billy gets into the
elevator and leaves]
[we see a young
Billy being recruited for pro baseball] Billy's Dad:
Tell me why Billy? What is it that makes him special? Scout #1:
It's very rare that you come upon a young man like Billy. Who can run,
who can field, who can throw, who can hit and who can hit with power.
Those five tools, you don't see that very often. Scout #2:
Most of the youngsters in the league and have an interest in have one
or two tools and we're hoping to develop and extra one. Your son has
five, I mean we're looking at a guy that's a potential superstar for us
in New York and the time is right now to get him started. Scout #1: We're
prepared to make a sizeable financial commitment. The Mets are gonna
stand behind Billy because we expect him to be our big league center
field. This check here represents the offer that the New York Mets
would be making to Billy. Billy's Mom:
You do know that he's been accepted to Stanford on a full scholarship? Scout #1: I
do. Billy's Mom: So
he can do both? Scout #1: Unfortunately
he can't do Stanford and professional baseball. He would have to pick
one or the other. If he wants to be the center fielder for the New York
Mets, he wants to be the baseball player, he really needs to accept
this as life's first occupation, a first career. We're all told at some
point in time that we can no longer play the children's game, we just
don't... don't know when that's gonna be. Some of us are told at
eighteen, some of us are told at forty, but we're all told. But this is
a once in a lifetime opportunity, we want you badly and we think that
this amount of money expresses that desire. Billy's Dad: Billy,
this is your decision. And whatever that decision is, you know it's
fine with your mother and I.
[Billy calls Peter up
late at night] Billy Beane: Hey,
it's Billy Beane. Peter Brand: What
time is it? Billy Beane: I
don't know. Listen, would you have drafted me in the first round? Peter Brand: What? Billy Beane: After
I left, you looked my up on your computer. Would you have drafted me in
the first round? Peter Brand: I
did, yeah. You were a good player. Billy Beane: Cut
the crap, man! Would you have drafted me in the first round? Peter Brand: I'd
have taken you in the ninth round. Left side and bonus. I imagine you
would have passed and taken the scholarship. Billy Beane: Yeah.
Pack you bags, Pete. I just bought you from the Cleveland Indians. [he hangs up the phone]
[first day in his job] Peter Brand: Hey,
Billy. I wanted you to see these player evaluations that you asked me
to do. [he hands Billy the
document] Billy Beane: I
asked you to do three. Peter Brand: Yeah.
Billy Beane: To
evaluate three players? Peter Brand: Yeah. Billy Beane: How
many did you do? Peter Brand: Forty
seven. Billy Beane: Okay. Peter Brand: Actually,
fifty one. I don't know why I lied just there.
[showing Billy his
equation for projecting their games] Peter Brand: So
using this equation on the upper left right here, I'm projecting that
we need to win at least ninety nine games in order to make it to the
pro season. We need to score at least eight hundred fourteen runs in
order to win those games and allow no more than six hundred and forty
five runs.
[showing Billy the
results of the code his run on the computer] Billy Beane: What's
this? Peter Brand: This
is a code that I've written to run your projections. This is building
in all the intelligence that we have to project players. Billy Beane: Okay. Peter Brand: It's
about getting things down to one number. Using stats to reread them,
we'll find the value of players that nobody else can see. People are
over looked for a variety of biased reasons and perceived flaws. Age,
appearance, personality. Bill James and Mathematics cuts straight
through that. Billy, of the twenty thousand knowable players for us to
consider, I believe that there's a championship team of twenty five
people that we can afford. Because everyone else in baseball under
values them. Like and island of misfit toys.
[to Billy, from his
projections] Peter Brand: Billy,
this is Chad Bradford. He's a relieve pitcher. He's one of the most
under valued players in baseball. His defect is that he throws funny.
Nobody in the big leagues chases that, because he looks funny.
He's got to be not just the best pitcher in our ball game, but one of
the most effective relieve pitchers in all of baseball.
[Art interrupts Billy as
he's about to have a meeting with the scouts and Peter] Art Howe:
It's not easy doing what I do under the cloud of one year contract. Billy Beane: Okay,
I understand that. I've been there. Art Howe: I
know. I know you have. A one year contract means the same thing to a
manager as it does to a player. There's not a lot of faith there. Which
is strange after a hundred and two and six. Billy Beane: I
see. If you lose the last game in the season, nobody gives a shit. Art Howe: So
it's on me now. Billy Beane: No,
Art. It's on me. And the kid is the new Assistant G.M.
[at the meeting with the
scouts] Billy Beane: Guys,
you're still trying to replace Giambi. I told you we can't do it. We
can't do it. Now what we might be able to do is recreate him. We create
him in the adding field. Grady Fuson: The
what? Billy Beane: Giambi's
on base percentage was four seventy seven. Damon's on base, three
twenty four and Almada's was two ninety one. Add that up and you get [he snaps his finger and
points to Peter sitting across from him] Peter Brand: Do
you want me to speak? Billy Beane: When
I'm pointing at you, yeah. Peter Brand: Ten
ninety two. Billy Beane: Divided
by three. [Billy snaps his finger
again] Peter Brand: Three
sixty four. Billy Beane: That's
what we're looking for. Three ball players...three ball players who's
average O.B.P is... [he snaps his finger
again and points to Peter] Peter Brand: Three
sixty four.
[at the meeting with his
scouts] Billy Beane: Okay,
here's what we want. Jason's little brother, Jeremy. Scout Barry: Billy,
that's trouble. John Poloni: Uh...Billy,
look. If I...if I may, he's certainly had his problems off the field,
but we know what he can't do on the field. There's reports about him on
the weed and strip clubs. Billy Beane: Well,
his on base percentage is all we're lookin' at now. And Jeremy
gets on base an awful lot for a guy who only cost two hundred and
eighty five thousand. Grady Fuson: Jeez,
Billy... Billy Beane: Number
two, David Justice. Ron Hopkins:
Oh, no! Grady Fuson: Not
a good idea, Billy. Ron Hopkins: Old
man Justice?
[referring to Billy's
decision to recruit David Justice] Grady Fuson: His
legs are gone. We'll be lucky to get sixty games out of him. Why do you
like him? [Billy points to Peter
to answer] Peter Brand: Because
he gets on base. Billy Beane: Okay,
number three. Scott Hatteberg. Scout Barry: Who? John Poloni: Hatteberg. Billy Beane: Exactly!
He sounds like an Oakland A already. Yes, he's had a little problem
with his elbow... Grady Fuson: A
little problem? He can't throw! Ron Hopkins: He's
a clear two sixty hitter. The best part of his career is over. Billy Beane: I
say it's just gettin' started. John Poloni: I
know Boston wants to cut him and no one wants to pick him up. Billy Beane: That's
good for us, he's cheap. Grady Fuson: Let
me get this straight. You're gonna get a guy that's been released by
half the organization in professional baseball because he's got
non-reparable nerve damage in his elbow and he can't throw! Billy Beane: He
can't throw and he can't field, but what can he do? Guys, check the
reports or I'm gonna point at Peter. [the scouts look at the
report] The Scouts: He
gets on base. Billy Beane: He
gets on base! John Poloni: So
he walks a lot. Billy Beane: He
gets on base a lot. Do I care if it's a walk or a hit? [looks over at Peter] Billy Beane: Pete? Peter Brand: You
do not. Billy Beane: I
do not.
Grady Fuson: Let
me get this straight. So you're not gonna bring in one, but three
defective players to replace Giambi? It's what I'm hearing.
John Poloni: You're
not buying into this Billy James bullshit, right? Billy Beane: This
is the new direction for the Oakland A's. We are card counters at the
Black Jack table, but we're gonna turn the odds on the casino. Grady Fuson: I
don't see it. Scout Bob: Seriously
guys, I think we have to remember this is the man. He answers to no one
except ownership and God. And he doesn't have to answer to us. We make
suggestions, he makes decisions. Grady Fuson: Look
that's all fine and well, but we've been working our asses off for the
last six and a half weeks to make this ball club better and you're
shitting all over it! Billy Beane: Hey,
this is not a discussion. Scout Barry: What
are we discussing? Billy Beane: Barry,
not a discussion.
[referring to Billy's
choice of Jeremy Giambi, David Justice and Scott Hatteberg] Ron Washington:
I think there's one thing you're forgetting here. None of those three
guys knows how to play for a space. Billy Beane: Well,
you're gonna have to teach one of them. Ron Washington: Teach?
Which one?
[Ron and Billy visit
Scott at his home] Billy Beane: How's
the elbow, Scott? Scott Hatteberg:
You know, it's good. It's really good, it's great. Uh...I can't throw
the ball. Billy Beane: Yeah,
you've thrown your last ball from behind home play, it's what I'd
say. Good news is, we want you in first. We want you to play first base
for the Oakland A's. Scott Hatteberg: Okay,
woh! I've only ever played catcher. Billy Beane:
Scott, you're not a catcher anymore. If you were our call wouldn't have
been the only one you'd gotten when your contract expired. Scott Hatteberg: Yeah.
Hey, listen. No, I...I appreciate it. Billy Beane:
You're welcome. Scott Hatteberg:
But the thing...the thing is uh... Billy Beane:
You don't know how to play first base. Scott? Scott Hatteberg: That's
right. Billy Beane:
It's not that hard, Scott. Tell him, Wash. Ron Washington: It's
incredibly hard. Billy Beane:
Hey, anything worth doing is. And we're gonna teach you.
Scott Hatteberg: You
want me to take Giambi's spot in first base? Billy Beane: Yeah. Scott Hatteberg: What
about the fans? Ron Washington: [sarcastically]
Yeah, maybe I can teach one of them. Billy Beane: The
fans don't...come on! The fans don't run my ball club.
[flashback to young
Billy playing in MLB and losing game after game] Voice of Sports Announcer:
There's not an organization in baseball who would not have taken the
chance on this young guy. It didn't pan out. It happens every year.
Some do, some don't. Two scouts can go into the mind of a young man and
determine whether he's really confident about what he can do. So he
gets to sign him based on his ability, but then he's gotta be
successful to be confident. And once he becomes confident that's when
you got something. You make a decision on what you see and things don't
pan out, you move on. That's baseball. Many are called, few are chosen.
Billy Beane: You
look unhappy, Grady. Why? Grady Fuson: Wow!
May I speak candidly? Billy Beane: Sure.
Go ahead. Grady Fuson: Major
league baseball and it's fans they're gonna be more than happy to throw
you and Google boy into the bus if you keep doing what you're doing
here. You don't put a team together with a computer, Billy. Billy Beane: No? Grady Fuson: No.
Baseball isn't just numbers, it's not science. If it was then anybody
could do what we're doing, but they can't because they don't know what
we know. They don't have our experience and they don't have our
intuition. Billy Beane: Okay. Grady Fuson: Billy,
you got a kid in there that's got a degree in Economics from Yale. You
got a scout here with twenty nine years of baseball experience. You're
listening to the wrong one. Now there are intangibles that only
baseball people understand. You're discounting what scouts have done
for a hundred and fifty years, even yourself!
Grady Fuson: This
is about you and your shit, isn't it? Twenty years ago some scout got
it wrong. Billy Beane: Woh!
Okay. Grady Fuson: Now
you're gonna declare war on the whole system. Billy Beane: Okay!
Okay. My turn. You don't have a crystal ball, you can't look at a kid
and predict his future any more than I can. I've sat at those kitchen
tables with you and listened to you tell those parents 'When I know, I
know! And when it comes to your son, I know'. And you don't. You don't! Grady Fuson: Okay,
I don't give a shit about friendship, this situation or the past. Major
league baseball thinks the way I think. You're not gonna win. And I'll
give you a nickel's worth of free advice. You're never gonna get
another job when Schott fires you after this catastrophic season you're
about to set us all up for. And you're gonna have to explain to your
kid why you work at a Dick's Sporting Goods. Billy Beane: I'm
not gonna fire you, Grady. [Grady puts his hand on
Billy's shoulder and Billy pushes it off] Grady Fuson: Fuck
you, Billy! Billy Beane: Now
I will.
Billy Beane: Tell
me about Bradford. Coach Bob:
Well I like him a little bit, but he's a specialty. He's not a guy that
you say the eighth inning is yours. Lefties versus righties, in my
opinion.
Coach Bob: Billy
I think we ought to talk about Hatteberg. Billy Beane: Go. Coach Bob: Now,
there's just no field for this spot. I think it's got a long shot that
you can have big league first base with him. Billy Beane: It's
day one of the first week. You can't judge just yet. Art Howe: No,
I think we can judge him. I like him. You know? But I can judge him.
The first base is the moon to him. Billy Beane: It
wasn't to Giambi? Giambi's the worst first baseman in all of baseball. Art Howe: You're
gonna compare him to Giambi. Billy Beane: What
are we talking about here? Art Howe: Alright. Billy Beane: What
do you think, Wash? Ron Washington: The
nice way to say it is uh...he lacks confidence. Billy Beane: Well
give him some.
[to Billy as they watch
the new players train] Billy Beane: [seriously] This
better work. [Peter gives him a
worried look] Billy Beane: I'm
just kiddin' you.
[as the first game of
the season is about to begin] Chad Bradford:
I wanted to say thank you for this opportunity. Billy Beane: Well,
we enjoy having you. It's gonna work out well for all of us. Chad Bradford: I
appreciate it, sir. Nobody's ever given me a chance like this before in
the big leagues Billy Beane: Nobody? Chad Bradford: Well
just you, sir. Billy Beane: Well,
it's a big day. One you won't forget. Chad Bradford: I
appreciate it. And sir, I just wanted to let you know that I'm gonna be
praying for you and your family. Billy Beane: No
problem.